Kickstarter Woes and Woahs

Someone started a geeklist on BoardGameGeek about games that you’ve backed on Kickstarter and any regrets you have with the system. While there are certainly projects I regret backing, there are far more that I’m glad I helped make a reality. Below are some of those standout games.

Most Disappointing

Glory to Rome: Black Box edition is the first game that comes to mind. Glory to Rome is a strategic game where the cards represent the actions you can perform, the buildings you can build, as well as the materials to build those buildings. I really enjoy games that feature this kind of mechanic, and after playing the original version once, I knew I’d get a copy at some point. The Kickstarter was to take the original game, which had cartoony graphics, and clean up the look and make it appear more professionally done. The art in the final version is amazing, and I can say without a doubt that I prefer the new art to the old.

However, the greatness of the art is only matched by the issues with the physical components of the game. Most copies have issues with some of the cards where they appear to be marked or burnt, the Jacks in the game (a special card) have flaking edges, and the box itself has ink on the inside of the lid from the rulebook as well as what appears to be water damage. Finally, the game took over a year to reach the backers, with limited updates that rarely answered questions. I couldn’t be happier with the art, but I couldn’t be more disappointed with the components and customer service.

Most Impressive

Viticulture is a game that is a bit of a strange fit for me, as I don’t drink at all, but the gameplay looked really well done, the art looked nice, and the wooden pieces (commonly referred to as meeples)… I don’t want to say that I got the game for the meeples, but it certainly didn’t hurt. However, when I backed the game, I assumed it would be just another game I backed. The designers were offering an interesting guarantee, though. If you get the game and don’t like it, you can send the game back and they’ll return your money. I’ve been burned by some games, so this made it all the more likely that I’d back this game.

Twelve hours after I backed it, I got a message from one of the designers and the person running the Kickstarter campaign. He asked if I was a store and for a link to the store’s webpage. I’m not, but I backed the game at a higher level, so I understand his comment. He also noted:

It looks like you’ve backed some great projects on Kickstarter, and I’m honored that you’d include Viticulture among them. I hope you enjoy the game! If you have any post-campaign advice for me, feel free to let me know.

Jamey had gone to my profile, noted that I’d backed other games, and wrote a personalized message to me. I don’t know how many other backers got messages like this one, but to contact at least some of your backers, thanking them for their support says a lot. On top of that, having done some research into what they’ve backed and sending out messages customized to each person says that the care that Jamey has for his customers is a very high priority. I am very excited to get this game and can’t wait to play it.

Most Ambitious

The Keep is a board game carrying system that removes the boxes and allows the boards, cards, and bits to be carried in a way that allows for more games in the same amount of space. As someone who runs lots of demos, I’ve tried figuring out a better way to carry more and more games with me, and The Keep seems like it should do just what I need. Robert has some lofty goals, but I think his idea is one that should be supported.

I contacted Robert about The Keep and he agreed to send me a prototype of The Great Chamber: a large padded sleeve with pockets for holding boards and some bits. I’m planning on testing its capacity with Power Grid, Arkham Horror, and several other games that would take advantage of a better method of transportation. If you can think of a game you want to have me try in the prototype, let me know in the comments below!

If you have a Kickstarter project that you think was noteworthy, either because of good or bad reasons, link it below in a comment and I’ll take a look.

Edit: Please note that while I’d love to tell you what will fit into a Magic Chamber, the plastic part more commonly used for bits and cards, I am not getting one to check out. However, Robert of Grumpy Owl Gamery will be following this post and will try to answer questions as well.

You may also like...

6 Responses

  1. Mike Podruchny says:

    I have been curious how well Carcassonne would fit in the keep. I assume the Magic Chamber is the best fit, but how many tiles fit it one and how much extra space is there?

  2. Robert says:

    Hi Mike!

    Most people store Carcassonne in a fabric bag to pull tiles from. That bag will fit in a Magic Chamber or could be replaced with a Magic Chamber. You can use dividers to separate tiles by expansion if you want. I wouldn’t recommend Bit Pits for the tiles, but for the meeples and tokens you certainly could. I’d expect 1.5 to 2 Magic Chambers to store Carcassone depending on which expansions you play. So, one MC for the tiles and one full of Bit Pits (at least 5 – 1 per player, plus additional for other tokens) to store the pieces or separated with Dividers to store the pieces.

    If you store in the Great Chamber, I would recommend leaving the tiles in the fabric bag and storing the tokens in the available small pockets. You will have plenty of room for other games.

    Robert

    • Mike Podruchny says:

      I currently keep everything in a box (from Really Useful Boxes: http://goo.gl/ek88y) with a custom divider system made from cardstock, small boxes for meeples (http://goo.gl/LqCSc) and bags for additional pieces (bridges, dragon/princess, resources, etc.) Right now it is the right size to fit everything for the base game plus the 9 expansions I have so far (213 tiles). All the tiles are split out so we can pick and choose which ones we want to play with at the start of each game. I really like the Keep for everything else, it just doesn’t quite seem efficient for tile based games.

      Thanks for the input Robert.

  3. As a big fan of the original GTR, I too am very disappointed in the Kickstarter version. The new cards are much flimsier than the originals, not only did my rule book have ink smudging, but the player mats did too, and for some unknown reason, they printed the mini player mat in reverse of the larger one. Add to this that my game was part of the lot that got shipped to Amsterdam by mistake and had to be returned to the US before finally getting shipped to me. Finally, it really aggravated me to see the game for sale on-line for almost 1/3 of what I paid via Kickstarter and 1 month before I finally got the game.

    • Ken says:

      I agree that the quality of the cardstock is worse than the original, as well as the ink issues and smudging. The mini player mat actually makes sense, but only if you realize that you can’t fit cards under it, so you simply put cards beside it. In order to highlight the correct side of the card, then, you have to switch which side of board relates to which side of the card. I agree that it’s strange, especially without any explanation. Your point on the final cost and shipment date is unfortunate, but accurate for many of the backers. My understanding is that as your copy took extra long, you got another free game. Is this correct, Lance?

  1. October 12, 2012

    […] games people would like to see tested. You can read about it and make requests on his site: http://geek-craft.com/wordpress/?p=622, his twitter, or here in our Kickstarter comments. While we have many games in our collection […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

BGL